Celebrating David Penny: Bridging Biology, Mathematics, and Evolution
The life and loss of David Penny, a Pioneer in Molecular Phylogenetics and Evolutionary Theory
Subscribe to Genomely for the latest discoveries and in-depth analyses in your inbox
Thank you to our subscribers for your continued support and passion for science!
David Penny's remarkable life and career not only bridged multiple disciplines but also transformed the fields of evolutionary biology, phylogenetics, and theoretical biology. This expanded account of his contributions provides a broader context for his life's work and intellectual pursuits, showcasing the depth of his scientific inquiries and the extent of his legacy.
Early Life and Education
Born on September 28, 1938, in Taumarunui, New Zealand, Edward David Penny grew up in a small town. Following the untimely death of his father, Penny’s mother raised him and his siblings while working various jobs to support the family. Penny attended New Plymouth Boys’ High School, where he was first inspired to pursue science after learning about the discovery of the structure of DNA. This curiosity eventually led him to study botany and chemistry at the University of Canterbury, followed by a PhD in botany at Yale University. His educational background laid the foundation for his pioneering work in molecular phylogenetics and evolutionary theory.
Shift to Evolutionary Biology and Key Contributions
After completing his PhD in 1965 and a postdoctoral stint at McMaster University, Penny returned to New Zealand and joined Massey University’s Department of Plant Biology in 1966. It was during this period that he shifted his focus from plant physiology to evolutionary biology, inspired by the groundbreaking work of Walter Fitch and others on using protein sequences to infer evolutionary relationships. This shift would lead Penny to become one of the principal architects of the burgeoning field of molecular phylogenetics.
A defining moment in his career came in the 1970s, when Penny tackled one of the most important challenges of evolutionary theory—its testability. In response to philosopher Karl Popper’s skepticism about whether Darwinism could be considered a testable scientific theory, Penny proposed a formal test for the theory of evolution. By comparing the evolutionary histories of different proteins across mammal species, he demonstrated that evolutionary trees constructed from different molecular data were more consistent than could be explained by chance, providing empirical support for Darwin’s theory of descent with modification. This work, which employed a branch-and-bound algorithm to explore evolutionary tree space, was a major breakthrough in evolutionary biology and laid the groundwork for future studies.
Advancing Phylogenetic Methods
Penny's work in developing methods to reconstruct evolutionary trees from molecular data was pivotal. His research focused on using DNA and protein sequences to trace the relationships between species, developing mathematical techniques and computational algorithms that helped revolutionize the field of phylogenetics. One of Penny's notable innovations was the Hadamard transform, a method that enabled researchers to calculate branch lengths directly from evolutionary data, providing more accurate reconstructions of phylogenetic trees.
In addition to advancing phylogenetic inference, Penny was also involved in the development of tree-building methods like the LogDet, which allowed researchers to account for evolutionary processes such as asymmetric nucleotide substitutions. This method became an essential tool in phylogenetics, enabling scientists to recover accurate evolutionary trees even when sequences evolved under complex models. These contributions made molecular phylogenetics a more rigorous and testable field, helping to solidify the link between molecular biology and evolutionary theory.
Exploring the Origins of Life and Eukaryotes
Penny’s work spanned numerous aspects of evolutionary biology, including the origins of life, the evolution of eukaryotes, and the diversification of plants and animals. His research on the RNA world hypothesis and the last universal common ancestor (LUCA) explored the possibility that early life forms used RNA rather than DNA as their primary genetic material. In 2006, he co-authored a paper that challenged the prevailing theory of genome fusion between archaea and bacteria as the origin of eukaryotes. Instead, Penny suggested that eukaryotes likely evolved through a process of simplification and sequence loss, rather than a straightforward linear progression from simpler to more complex forms.
This idea, that evolution could proceed in multiple directions — including "backwards” and “sideways" — was a hallmark of Penny’s thinking. His work emphasized the importance of competition, predation, and ecological interactions in shaping evolutionary trajectories, arguing that biological processes played an active role in evolution, rather than being passive responses to environmental changes.
Bird Evolution and Moa Research
In the realm of animal evolution, Penny made significant contributions to our understanding of bird diversification. His molecular clock studies revealed that the diversification of mammals and birds began well before the Cretaceous-Paleogene extinction event, which was previously thought to be the catalyst for their radiation. This finding challenged the established timeline and prompted a re-evaluation of the evolutionary history of birds and mammals.
Penny’s research on New Zealand’s iconic moa further highlighted his ability to challenge conventional wisdom. Working with colleagues, Penny demonstrated that moa — once thought to be the result of continental drift — likely flew to New Zealand before evolving into flightless giants. This work underscored Penny’s ability to combine molecular data with ecological and geological insights to reshape our understanding of evolutionary history.
Leadership and Influence in Science
Throughout his career, David Penny held numerous leadership positions, both in New Zealand and internationally. He served as president of the Society for Molecular Biology and Evolution, the Society of Systematic Biologists, and the New Zealand Association of Scientists. Penny’s role as co-director of the Allan Wilson Centre for Molecular Ecology and Evolution from 2002 to 2010 was a testament to his influence in advancing evolutionary biology in New Zealand and beyond.
Penny’s contributions to science were recognized with multiple awards, including New Zealand’s highest scientific honor, the Rutherford Medal, in 2004. He was also made a Companion of the New Zealand Order of Merit (CNZM) and was elected a Foreign Associate of the National Academy of Sciences in 2018, further cementing his legacy as one of the most influential evolutionary biologists of his generation.
A Legacy of Interdisciplinary Collaboration
A commitment to fostering interdisciplinary collaboration characterized David Penny’s career. His ability to bring together biologists, mathematicians, and computer scientists led to groundbreaking innovations in phylogenetics and evolutionary biology. His annual phylogenomics workshops in New Zealand became a hub for international collaboration, attracting researchers from diverse fields to engage in cross-disciplinary research. Penny’s collaborative approach not only advanced the field of molecular phylogenetics but also ensured that his students and colleagues were well-equipped to continue testing and refining evolutionary hypotheses long after his retirement.
David Penny leaves behind not only a wealth of scientific discoveries but also a community of researchers who carry forward his work, continually exploring and testing the evolutionary processes that he dedicated his life to understanding.